Resolved! Solved

Original topic:

BA Selection - Non Transparent, Favouritism and vague criteria?

(Topic created on: 07-14-2022 01:50 PM)
2551 Views
Sid_Karna
Expert Level 5
Options
Others

So, we all know that the BA selection just got completed and some 11 people were selected. Congrats to all. But, as active members of this platform some of us have some genuine concerns and objections.

  1. The Criteria for selection is UNKNOWN and VAGUE : Nobody made this clear and active members of this community are not selected. People who have made less than 10 posts and have ZERO solutions are selected. Now, you may say that the activity on this platform is not considered. But, then this is the PRIMARY community and platform for Samsung India users, not Instagram or Twitter or Youtube. People come HERE for solutions and to share experiences. So, no value for this platform?
  2. Who selects BAs?: Are the current BAs part of this process? If yes, it's unfair as many of these are people who have had debates with members and has personal grudges, which knowingly or unknowingly will affect the selection process. So, involving them is not a fair thing.
  3. What exactly do you expect from the candidates?: Blind promotion and appreciation of the brand? Or people with social media following who can help in advertising the products? Or genuine people who does criticism and appreciation respectively when warranted? Or people who are Doctors, engineers or Group A govt.  employees who can help improving the brand value??

I am someone who incidentally decided to quit this platform yesterday, hence the name change. However, I thought I should make this post before doing so. If all you required was people with high profile jobs like Doctors and/or people with social media following, you should have made this clear without making  others like us wasting our time. Otherwise, you should show the integrity to publicise the selection procedure, criteria and the selection panel.

I hereby register my strong disappointment, dissatisfaction and objection to the BA selection gimmick. I am not the only one with objection. And I am not surprised that I am not selected as I was sure about it because I reacted strongly for the people who were facing S20plus display issues and mass exynos 9611 motherboard failure. Nevertheless, I am surprised about the non selection some of my friends.

profile sid.pngStrange.pngUDay.pngAshu.pngphoto_2022-07-14_13-45-48.jpg

 

8 Solutions


Accepted Solutions
Solution
MuzikD
Expert Level 2
Others
Never interested in these stuffs coz of many reasons, one of them u explained in post. But these are all valid points. Keen to know the explanation if they have any.

View solution in context

Solution
Lovecracko
Active Level 3
Others
Well that's the problem..they are afraid to select u as u may talk against them..and the the truth always hurts bro for them the brand image is important

View solution in context

Solution
Anonymous
Not applicable
Others
Not surprised at all...was waiting for this. 🤣 🤣 Bhai don't expect any BA to respond but they will surely see this and discuss in their own secret groups. If admin responds then you should take a lottery, because you will win that too if you are that much lucky to get reply from Admin.

View solution in context

Solution
Gst26
Expert Level 5
Others
Bro.. till 2021 I was very much active on this forum and due to my activeness and participation I have been offered twice as a "BA" without being even applying bt i have not shown any interest.. Since i have seen that after becoming "BA" you can't be on a neutral Side, you need to go by One direction only 🤣 🤣 We were 2-3 Users who really worked to make this forum very Smooth so we were on hatred side to many a times...we have highlighted wrong prize selection criteria, Spamming activities & many more for this forum bt not able to changed much, So i changed myself 🤣 🤣 Sharing some links what wrong was going on & what pain we have beared...
https://r2.community.samsung.com/t5/Community-Guidelines/Leaving-This-Forum-Injustice-amp-Wrong-Deci...

https://r2.community.samsung.com/t5/Community-Guidelines/Members-App-Needs-Contents-Sexual-or-P-o-r-...

https://r2.community.samsung.com/t5/Others/How-Leveling-System-works-My-Conclusion-on-my-Pro-rata-ba...
Screenshot_20220701-222542_Gmail_21774_1656694550.jpg

View solution in context

Solution
Others
Not surprised because I had a talk with YashAgarwal, indiantrueindian, Sidabhi and they said that the selection process is juts random. I even got some stuff from community manager Avinav (old) about ba thing that honestly he was transparent in fact he had Made a post about BA form openly and pin 📌 on top so that everyone can see and made a transparent post regarding all selected BAs also

View solution in context

Solution
Others
😰 😰... from previous history of hangsung..we know bro.. Don't forget this is hangsung..and every worst thing possible here only.. they offer contest for everyone.. but they select winners from BA ( selected.. their relatives or something and few selected for eye wash ) .... never ever you will not be able to win if you are not BA ... . And what are their contribution to community? It's a big '0 '.. so don't be sad bro ... I faced this really before also ..

View solution in context

Solution
Ab_Heartsy
Expert Level 3
Others
Yes bro🤗 totally resonate with ur concerns over the level of transparency in BA selections and those many contests+results too 🙄.
Doesn't know about Ba selection criteria n that selection page coz I didn't apply n don't want to apply in future also coz of my life decisions n principles.

But I feel the admin or other BA's or moderators should be clear with the process atleast once in a while, after all it's their responsibility towards the platform isn't it?🤔,
I remember the selection process first didn't say it wasn't available for people below 18age, but later changed it. It makes me feel these are not thought out clearly or taken with respective seriousness with the people who are making it.?
So that's what I'm expecting too from the platform, doesn't take anything seriously here😅😂🤭

Also if u look at real world big brand BA's, any BA in the real world is there to promote n make sales for the brand and it also involves being keeping quite when brand gets into problems, but then again BA position comes with sacrificing some of ur integrity for the money n the others things that comes with it, no issues for me coz it's each people's individual choice. People can be whatever they want but some transparency n integrity is expected?🥴 maybe 60% transparency?😅

View solution in context

Solution
Others
They just want people who can do promotions, come on unpacked events and do Samsung zindabad
They don't want people like us who support the brand on good thing and take out negative points when it's wrong! No! They just want people who do 'Samsung ki taarefei'n only!'

View solution in context

50 Comments
Strangeneria
Expert Level 5
Others
Just want to know the criteria 🤔
Sid_Karna
Expert Level 5
Others

I have added the profiles of some of us who were not considered. Let's see the justification IF AT ALL anyone replies.

Anonymous
Not applicable
Others
Never existed 😂😂
Others
Hmm20220709_062512_25842_1657328112.jpg
Sid_Karna
Expert Level 5
Others

Meaning? Englishil oru post kandal athinu Englishil reply idanam..allathe vayi thonnuna bhashayil alla.

Others
Seems like you aren't pro player, just a joke
Sid_Karna
Expert Level 5
Others

No, bro I am not a pro player. Just a common user. I am waiting for the definition of "pro players" from responsible people so that poor me can become a pro in the future. 😊

animeshmodi
Expert Level 5
Others
From where to know the BA results, who have won?
Sid_Karna
Expert Level 5
Others

There was one post by Yashagarwal. However, the complete list is not there as usual...no transparency. Only the one's who got selected know that they are selected. And since most of them are not even active here, we may never know who all got selected.